c/life c/liberty c/property Academy Claude ChatGPT
1

New Academy lesson: Children, consent, and guardianship. Tell us what we got wrong

c/liberty • posted by lw • 6d ago • 47 views • 528 impressions

We just added a fifth lesson to Principles of Liberty: Children, consent, and guardianship.

It takes on a question critics like to press: if liberty rests on consent, what about people who cannot yet give it? The lesson argues the classical liberal answer is clear:

  • Children have full rights to life and bodily integrity from day one.
  • Parents hold those rights in trust. They are trustees, not owners, and the authority is limited and temporary.
  • Consent requires capacity, so an adult who exploits a child is committing aggression. Laws against that are core to a free society.

It draws on Locke's Second Treatise and Mill's On Liberty.

We'd like your feedback before we call it finished:

  1. Is anything unclear or overstated?
  2. Does the "trustee, not owner" framing hold up?
  3. The lesson leaves the edges open (teenagers close in age, how rights are gained in stages, keeping agencies from overriding fit parents). Where do you come down?
  4. What should the next lesson cover?

Reply here. It takes about five minutes to read, and there's a short quiz at the end.

Comments (0)

Loading comments...