Children, consent, and guardianship
The hard case
Liberty rests on consent. Adults may make their own choices, including bad ones, because their lives are their own. So what about people who cannot yet give consent? Critics like to press this point, as though a philosophy of freedom must either ignore children or abandon them. It does neither. The classical liberal answer is old, clear, and strict.
Born to freedom, not yet in it
Locke took up the question directly in the Second Treatise:
Children, I confess, are not born in this full state of equality, though they are born to it. Their parents have a sort of rule and jurisdiction over them, when they come into the world, and for some time after; but it is but a temporary one. The bonds of this subjection are like the swaddling clothes they are wrapt up in, and supported by, in the weakness of their infancy: age and reason as they grow up, loosen them, till at length they drop quite off, and leave a man at his own free disposal.
A child has the same rights to life and bodily integrity as any adult, from the first day. What a child lacks is the developed reason needed to exercise full liberty: to weigh consequences, to bind themselves by agreement, to consent.
John Stuart Mill drew the same line. Immediately after stating that a person is sovereign over their own body and mind, he added that the principle applies only to people "in the maturity of their faculties," and that those still in the care of others "must be protected against their own actions as well as against external injury."
Parents are trustees, not owners
Someone has to guard a child's rights until the child can. That duty falls first on parents. Locke is careful about where their authority comes from:
The power, then, that parents have over their children, arises from that duty which is incumbent on them, to take care of their off-spring, during the imperfect state of childhood.
The duty comes first and the power follows from it. Three things result.
- Parental authority is real. Parents decide how their children are raised, taught, and disciplined, and the state should not second-guess ordinary family choices.
- It is limited. A trustee acts for the benefit of the person whose interests they hold. A parent who abuses or abandons a child is not exercising parental rights. They are breaking the trust those rights come from.
- It is temporary. The point of the arrangement is to produce a free adult. Authority loosens as reason grows, and then it ends.
Consent requires capacity
A choice counts as consent only when the person making it understands what they are agreeing to and is free to refuse. Children do not meet that standard, least of all with an adult who holds every advantage in size, experience, and power.
That is why sexual contact between an adult and a child is never a "victimless" or "consensual" act. No valid consent exists, so it is aggression against a person who cannot defend themselves, and stopping aggression is the one job even the most limited government has. Laws against child abuse are among the few a free society cannot do without. They are not exceptions to liberty.
Why the law draws a line by age
Maturity arrives gradually and at different times for different people, so any fixed age is imperfect. The law uses one anyway, for a reason that should appeal to anyone who distrusts arbitrary power: a clear rule protects better than a case-by-case judgment. It tells every adult in advance where the line is, and it spares a child from having to prove in court that they were not ready.
Honest debate remains at the edges. People disagree about how the law should treat two teenagers close in age, how young adults gain rights in stages, and how to keep child-protection agencies from overriding fit parents. Those are questions about where and how to draw the line. Whether adults may exploit children is not among them.
Try it
Think of one decision your parents made for you at ten that you would have made differently. Were they acting as an owner or as a trustee? Then name one power that parents hold and one that no parent can hold, and explain the difference in a sentence. Bring your answer to the discussion thread.
Sources are public domain: Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1689), chapter 6, sections 55 and 58; Mill, On Liberty (1859), chapter 1.