Border agents copied an ICE critic's phone without a warrant. A federal judge just locked the data
Immigration lawyer Andrew Lattarulo posts Instagram videos (57,000+ followers) telling immigrants their rights and warning them about ICE tactics. When he flew home to Boston from a weekend in Aruba, CBP and HSI agents seized his phone at Logan Airport without a warrant and downloaded a full copy of it, privileged attorney-client files included.
On Nov. 13, U.S. District Judge Allison Burroughs (D. Mass.) granted a preliminary injunction barring DHS from searching that data, finding he is likely to win his First Amendment retaliation claim:
- His colleague, who had the same or greater access to the firm records the government said it wanted but didn't speak out publicly, flew back a day earlier and was not searched.
- The government offered no evidence that phone searches are normal in this kind of employment probe, and grabbed his phone just three days into a 10-business-day response window.
- The judge also doubted the "border search exception" can cover a domestic investigation unrelated to the border crossing itself.
Why it matters: seven appeals courts say agents never need a warrant to search a phone at the border. This ruling is a reminder that the border isn't a free pass to punish critics.
Source: Reason
Loading comments...